When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference proceeding with ISSN or ISBNChapter

Abstract

Sunsets are everywhere. Nightly they appear, vast and humbling, orange, pink and purple. Like snowflakes, it is said that every single one is different. Natural, ephemeral and beautiful, they constitute exactly the kind of subject that prompts people to reach for a camera: the fleeting spectacle that photography seems made to capture; the momentary vision that deserves immortalising. Sunset photographs, however, are a different matter. They have come to represent the most predictable, culturally devalued and banal of image-making practices. Critics dismiss them as ‘chocolate box’ or ‘picture postcard’; they are seen as cliche s. The beauty of a sunset can be transformed, in a photograph, into something cloying. Their very ubiquity is what seems to repel; photography has tainted what it sought to cherish through overuse. It seems to miniaturise natural grandeur and render it kitsch. In this chapter, I sketch in the origins of some of this critique, and take apart some of the assumptions beneath the dismissals, looking at amateur sunset photographs in both historical and contemporary practice.

'When is a Cliche not a Cliche?' is a 3000-word essay reflecting on the ways that multiple photographs of popular subjects in popular practice can be understood. Originally published as part of the 'Reconsidering Amateur Photography' strand for the Science Museum-funded project www.eitherand.org, this 2018 revised version forms part of the section 'Mass Culture and the Politics of Distinction' in the book Photography Reframed, edited by Ben Burbridge and Annebella Pollen.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationPhotography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture
EditorsBen Burbridge, Annebella Pollen
Place of PublicationLondon
PublisherI.B.Tauris
Chapter9
Pages74-81
Number of pages8
ISBN (Print)9781784538835
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2018

Fingerprint

Cliché
Photography
Spectacle
Grandeur
Ephemeral
Kitsch
Amateur
Amateur Photography
Pollen
Science museum
Prompts
Mass Culture
Picture Postcards
Render

Cite this

Pollen, A. (2018). When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets. In B. Burbridge, & A. Pollen (Eds.), Photography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture (pp. 74-81). London: I.B.Tauris.
Pollen, Annebella. / When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets. Photography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture. editor / Ben Burbridge ; Annebella Pollen. London : I.B.Tauris, 2018. pp. 74-81
@inbook{5e761b0d904d47189b20c2a3fad280b5,
title = "When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets",
abstract = "Sunsets are everywhere. Nightly they appear, vast and humbling, orange, pink and purple. Like snowflakes, it is said that every single one is different. Natural, ephemeral and beautiful, they constitute exactly the kind of subject that prompts people to reach for a camera: the fleeting spectacle that photography seems made to capture; the momentary vision that deserves immortalising. Sunset photographs, however, are a different matter. They have come to represent the most predictable, culturally devalued and banal of image-making practices. Critics dismiss them as ‘chocolate box’ or ‘picture postcard’; they are seen as cliche s. The beauty of a sunset can be transformed, in a photograph, into something cloying. Their very ubiquity is what seems to repel; photography has tainted what it sought to cherish through overuse. It seems to miniaturise natural grandeur and render it kitsch. In this chapter, I sketch in the origins of some of this critique, and take apart some of the assumptions beneath the dismissals, looking at amateur sunset photographs in both historical and contemporary practice.'When is a Cliche not a Cliche?' is a 3000-word essay reflecting on the ways that multiple photographs of popular subjects in popular practice can be understood. Originally published as part of the 'Reconsidering Amateur Photography' strand for the Science Museum-funded project www.eitherand.org, this 2018 revised version forms part of the section 'Mass Culture and the Politics of Distinction' in the book Photography Reframed, edited by Ben Burbridge and Annebella Pollen.",
author = "Annebella Pollen",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "1",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781784538835",
pages = "74--81",
editor = "Ben Burbridge and Annebella Pollen",
booktitle = "Photography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture",
publisher = "I.B.Tauris",

}

Pollen, A 2018, When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets. in B Burbridge & A Pollen (eds), Photography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture. I.B.Tauris, London, pp. 74-81.

When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets. / Pollen, Annebella.

Photography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture. ed. / Ben Burbridge; Annebella Pollen. London : I.B.Tauris, 2018. p. 74-81.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference proceeding with ISSN or ISBNChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets

AU - Pollen, Annebella

PY - 2018/8/1

Y1 - 2018/8/1

N2 - Sunsets are everywhere. Nightly they appear, vast and humbling, orange, pink and purple. Like snowflakes, it is said that every single one is different. Natural, ephemeral and beautiful, they constitute exactly the kind of subject that prompts people to reach for a camera: the fleeting spectacle that photography seems made to capture; the momentary vision that deserves immortalising. Sunset photographs, however, are a different matter. They have come to represent the most predictable, culturally devalued and banal of image-making practices. Critics dismiss them as ‘chocolate box’ or ‘picture postcard’; they are seen as cliche s. The beauty of a sunset can be transformed, in a photograph, into something cloying. Their very ubiquity is what seems to repel; photography has tainted what it sought to cherish through overuse. It seems to miniaturise natural grandeur and render it kitsch. In this chapter, I sketch in the origins of some of this critique, and take apart some of the assumptions beneath the dismissals, looking at amateur sunset photographs in both historical and contemporary practice.'When is a Cliche not a Cliche?' is a 3000-word essay reflecting on the ways that multiple photographs of popular subjects in popular practice can be understood. Originally published as part of the 'Reconsidering Amateur Photography' strand for the Science Museum-funded project www.eitherand.org, this 2018 revised version forms part of the section 'Mass Culture and the Politics of Distinction' in the book Photography Reframed, edited by Ben Burbridge and Annebella Pollen.

AB - Sunsets are everywhere. Nightly they appear, vast and humbling, orange, pink and purple. Like snowflakes, it is said that every single one is different. Natural, ephemeral and beautiful, they constitute exactly the kind of subject that prompts people to reach for a camera: the fleeting spectacle that photography seems made to capture; the momentary vision that deserves immortalising. Sunset photographs, however, are a different matter. They have come to represent the most predictable, culturally devalued and banal of image-making practices. Critics dismiss them as ‘chocolate box’ or ‘picture postcard’; they are seen as cliche s. The beauty of a sunset can be transformed, in a photograph, into something cloying. Their very ubiquity is what seems to repel; photography has tainted what it sought to cherish through overuse. It seems to miniaturise natural grandeur and render it kitsch. In this chapter, I sketch in the origins of some of this critique, and take apart some of the assumptions beneath the dismissals, looking at amateur sunset photographs in both historical and contemporary practice.'When is a Cliche not a Cliche?' is a 3000-word essay reflecting on the ways that multiple photographs of popular subjects in popular practice can be understood. Originally published as part of the 'Reconsidering Amateur Photography' strand for the Science Museum-funded project www.eitherand.org, this 2018 revised version forms part of the section 'Mass Culture and the Politics of Distinction' in the book Photography Reframed, edited by Ben Burbridge and Annebella Pollen.

UR - https://ibtauris.com/Books/The-arts/Photography--photographs/Photography-Reframed-New-Visions-in-Contemporary-Photographic-Culture?menuitem=%7B51A6F587-FDE7-4FB6-876A-D0E957B93869%7D

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781784538835

SP - 74

EP - 81

BT - Photography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture

A2 - Burbridge, Ben

A2 - Pollen, Annebella

PB - I.B.Tauris

CY - London

ER -

Pollen A. When is a Cliche not a Cliche? Reconsidering Mass-Produced Sunsets. In Burbridge B, Pollen A, editors, Photography Reframed: New Visions in Contemporary Photographic Culture. London: I.B.Tauris. 2018. p. 74-81