Are Scandinavian countries different? A comparison of relative incomes for older people in OECD nations

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Recent research has cast some doubt on the consistency of models that isolate Scandinavian countries as different to other nations in terms of egalitarian welfare states. For example, it has been argued that if occupational welfare polices have their contribution to national welfare better accounted for in comparative models, or if there is a focus on specific aspects of welfare coverage, then Scandinavian welfare states look less different to other European countries. Using case-based methods that try to balance the demand for generalizations and the qualitative integrity of the case, this research examines the specific case of income protection for the older population post-retirement, to see if Scandinavian countries emerge as consistently different when compared with other OECD nations. Scandinavia can be clearly identified in a separate cluster, but it is not alone and other countries also share its similarities. In particular, Scandinavia emerges in a cluster that provides more income replacement and protection for women. In part, this is reinforced by the high rate of labour participation by women in Scandinavian countries. However, there is little evidence of Scandinavian countries retaining noticeable differences and divergence in income protection policies for men.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)114-130
Number of pages17
JournalSocial Policy & Administration
Volume45
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2011

Fingerprint

Relative income
Income
Older people
Welfare state
Scandinavia
Replacement
Divergence
Case research
Labor
Retirement
Participation
Integrity
European countries
Police

Keywords

  • income inequality
  • older people
  • cluster analysis

Cite this

@article{f4f8319cb0d343988cfb3b8a6cd4da06,
title = "Are Scandinavian countries different? A comparison of relative incomes for older people in OECD nations",
abstract = "Recent research has cast some doubt on the consistency of models that isolate Scandinavian countries as different to other nations in terms of egalitarian welfare states. For example, it has been argued that if occupational welfare polices have their contribution to national welfare better accounted for in comparative models, or if there is a focus on specific aspects of welfare coverage, then Scandinavian welfare states look less different to other European countries. Using case-based methods that try to balance the demand for generalizations and the qualitative integrity of the case, this research examines the specific case of income protection for the older population post-retirement, to see if Scandinavian countries emerge as consistently different when compared with other OECD nations. Scandinavia can be clearly identified in a separate cluster, but it is not alone and other countries also share its similarities. In particular, Scandinavia emerges in a cluster that provides more income replacement and protection for women. In part, this is reinforced by the high rate of labour participation by women in Scandinavian countries. However, there is little evidence of Scandinavian countries retaining noticeable differences and divergence in income protection policies for men.",
keywords = "income inequality, older people, cluster analysis",
author = "Philip Haynes",
year = "2011",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/j.1467-9515.2010.00759.x",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "114--130",
journal = "Social Policy & Administration",
issn = "0144-5596",
number = "2",

}

Are Scandinavian countries different? A comparison of relative incomes for older people in OECD nations. / Haynes, Philip.

In: Social Policy & Administration, Vol. 45, No. 2, 01.04.2011, p. 114-130.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Are Scandinavian countries different? A comparison of relative incomes for older people in OECD nations

AU - Haynes, Philip

PY - 2011/4/1

Y1 - 2011/4/1

N2 - Recent research has cast some doubt on the consistency of models that isolate Scandinavian countries as different to other nations in terms of egalitarian welfare states. For example, it has been argued that if occupational welfare polices have their contribution to national welfare better accounted for in comparative models, or if there is a focus on specific aspects of welfare coverage, then Scandinavian welfare states look less different to other European countries. Using case-based methods that try to balance the demand for generalizations and the qualitative integrity of the case, this research examines the specific case of income protection for the older population post-retirement, to see if Scandinavian countries emerge as consistently different when compared with other OECD nations. Scandinavia can be clearly identified in a separate cluster, but it is not alone and other countries also share its similarities. In particular, Scandinavia emerges in a cluster that provides more income replacement and protection for women. In part, this is reinforced by the high rate of labour participation by women in Scandinavian countries. However, there is little evidence of Scandinavian countries retaining noticeable differences and divergence in income protection policies for men.

AB - Recent research has cast some doubt on the consistency of models that isolate Scandinavian countries as different to other nations in terms of egalitarian welfare states. For example, it has been argued that if occupational welfare polices have their contribution to national welfare better accounted for in comparative models, or if there is a focus on specific aspects of welfare coverage, then Scandinavian welfare states look less different to other European countries. Using case-based methods that try to balance the demand for generalizations and the qualitative integrity of the case, this research examines the specific case of income protection for the older population post-retirement, to see if Scandinavian countries emerge as consistently different when compared with other OECD nations. Scandinavia can be clearly identified in a separate cluster, but it is not alone and other countries also share its similarities. In particular, Scandinavia emerges in a cluster that provides more income replacement and protection for women. In part, this is reinforced by the high rate of labour participation by women in Scandinavian countries. However, there is little evidence of Scandinavian countries retaining noticeable differences and divergence in income protection policies for men.

KW - income inequality

KW - older people

KW - cluster analysis

U2 - 10.1111/j.1467-9515.2010.00759.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1467-9515.2010.00759.x

M3 - Article

VL - 45

SP - 114

EP - 130

JO - Social Policy & Administration

JF - Social Policy & Administration

SN - 0144-5596

IS - 2

ER -