Skip to search boxSkip to navigationSkip to main content

Helping novice, non-specialist teachers foster self-efficacy in primary art and design through collaborative creativity: the role of balance between agency and instruction

  • Alison Hermon(Author)
Student thesis:
Student thesis
Doctoral Thesis

About the thesis

This thesis examines the role of balance between agency and instruction in<br/>primary art and design (A&D). It explores the potential of collaborative<br/>creativity, a creative pedagogy advocating a balance between agency and<br/>instruction to foster pupils’ and non-specialist newly qualified teachers’<br/>(NQTs) self-efficacy in art production. Bandura’s self-efficacy theory is<br/>crucial to this endeavour as research suggests that pupils’ self-efficacy may<br/>be constrained by pedagogy promoting an imbalance between instruction<br/>and agency, potentially exacerbated by the current A&D curriculum and<br/>NQTs’ own lack of self-efficacy. Nevertheless, whilst educational research<br/>indicates the potential of collaborative creativity, the hypothesis that it can<br/>support children’s and NQTs’ self-efficacy in A&D by promoting a balance<br/>between agency and instruction, is less well researched. This hypothesis is<br/>tested through the development of a Creative Attributes Framework for<br/>Collaborative Creativity (CAFCC) - a research tool and product for this<br/>purpose.<br/><br/>Drawing on a theory-led collective case study in three phases, the<br/>researcher promoted collaborative creativity supported by an artistic<br/>communities of practice ethos with three primary A&D specialist teachers<br/>working online in Phase 1, and with three primary, non-specialist NQTs<br/>based in one school in Phases 2 and 3, to examine this area and develop<br/>the CAFCC. Audio recording captured the online interactions in Phase 1,<br/>discussing ideas for phases 2 and 3. Video and visual methods recorded<br/>the face-to-face interactions of practice-led research in the Phase 2 A&D<br/>mastery workshops led by the researcher, and the Phase 3 A&D lessons led<br/>by the NQTs. Audio recording was used for interviews and reflections. Data<br/>analysis focused on critical examination of the collaborative creativity<br/>hypothesis in relation to the findings and final Witch’s Hat CAFCC<br/>development.<br/><br/>This thesis contributes evidence there is scope for addressing non-specialist<br/>NQTs’ and children’s low self-efficacy in primary A&D through collaborative<br/>creativity in artistic communities of practice. This focus was instrumental in<br/>supporting certain NQTs’ engagement with their own creative practice in<br/>overlapping positions of ‘artist-learners’ and ‘artist-teachers’ in Phase 3,<br/>aligned with two education for emancipation models. Findings indicate how<br/>these roles encouraged a more democratic, reciprocal ethos to foster a<br/>balance of children’s and class teachers’ positive perceptions of each other<br/>to promote collaborative creativity. Nevertheless, evidence suggests some<br/>may struggle to develop their self-efficacy in these roles linked with<br/>pedagogies of repression associated with neoliberal values of policy in<br/>primary A&D and wider education.<br/><br/><br/>

Thesis information

Thesis Award Date

06/2024

Qualification Level

Doctoral Thesis

Original Language

English

Supervisors

Nadia Edmond (Supervisor)
Charlotte Gould (Supervisor)

Awarding Institution