Fathers of the nation: Presidential masculinity in the Manhattan novel from Kennedy to Trump (1963-2025)
- Lucy Stevens(Author)
Student thesis:
Student thesis
Doctoral Thesis
About the thesis
This thesis examines gendered constructions of the U.S. presidency in the contemporary Manhattan novel, arguing that the president functions not simply as a political leader but as a performative model of hegemonic masculinity in modern America. Drawing on Freudian psychoanalytic theory, Judith Butler’s gender performativity, and Richard Neustadt’s concept of informal presidential power, it examines the relationship between citizens, patriarchal authority, and the performative construction of masculine identity. Focusing on five presidential periods from Kennedy to Trump, the study brings political science, gender theory, cultural history, and literary studies into dialogue with the techniques and legacy of New Journalism. <br/>The thesis demonstrates that Manhattan novels depict the president as both a catalyst and mirror for their male protagonists’ crises. Presidential masculinity operates as a model that is simultaneously unattainable and compulsory: protagonists imitate, reject, distort, or attempt to compensate for the masculine ideal embodied by the president. This ideal originates from George Washington, and is rooted in paternal authority, religious legitimacy, bodily virility, and public performance. In tracing these aspects from Kennedy’s televisual charisma through Reagan’s paternal spectacle, Bush’s heroic national protection, Obama’s intellectual and plural masculinity, and Trump’s radicalisation of presidential performance, the thesis demonstrates that the presidential masculine ideal is neither fixed nor progressively transformed. These characteristics are rearticulated in response to changing political, cultural, and media environments. Yet the novels reveal that presidential masculinity does not simply provide an example of hegemonic masculinity; it establishes a paternal hierarchy against which subordinate men continually measure themselves. <br/>The thesis further establishes Manhattan as a particularly productive literary site for examining this process. Its density, visibility, competitive culture, diversity, and concentration of media and political power intensify the pressures of masculine self-fashioning. The apparent stability of presidential authority is therefore undermined by the repetitive performances, media circulation, and recognition through which it is maintained.<br/>
