The history of the care programme approach in England: where did it go wrong?
- A. Simpson,
- C. Miller,
- L. Bowers
Research output:
Contribution to journal
Article
Research
Peer-reviewAbout the research
Background: The Care Programme Approach (CPA) was introduced in England in 1991 as a form of case management to improve community care for people with severe mental illness. It helped services maintain contact with users but failed to provide comprehensive, co-ordinated care and is associated with increased bed use
Aim: To describe and evaluate the introduction, implementation and development of the CPA and identify reasons for its relative failure.
Method: A critical review of key events, audits, reports, research and policies that shaped the CPA.
Results: Reasons for the relative failure of the CPA included the socio-political and financial context, clinicians' resistance to political and managerial interference, and the bureaucratic, complex and time-consuming nature of the policy. This reduced face-to-face contact whilst contributing to an emergent 'blame culture' and defensive psychiatric practice. The CPA also presumed levels of community resources and interprofessional teamwork that were frequently absent
Conclusions: The CPA was a flawed policy introduced insensitively into an inhospitable environment. It was destined to fail and after more than a decade remains ineffectively implemented. Changes introduced recently may have contradictory influences on the ability of services to provide effective case management but remain to be evaluated.
Documents and links
License:Unspecified
Final published version
License:Unspecified
Research output information
Output type
Research output:
Contribution to journal
Article
Research
Peer-reviewOriginal language
EnglishPages from-to (Number of pages)
Pages 489-504 (16 pages)Journal (Volume, Issue Number)
Journal of Mental Health (Volume 12, Issue 5)Publication milestones
- Published - 10/2003
Publication status
Published - 10/2003
