Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference proceeding with ISSN or ISBNChapter

Abstract

By the first half of the twentieth century, vast numbers of the UK’s towns and cities had formed their own municipal museums and their collections had swelled with non-European material culture sourced from across the world. Such institutions provided a British public with a unique medium through which to comprehend and appropriate their Empire and its peoples, but what were the messages that provincial museums conveyed, and how where they received by local audiences? What was the relationship between intended meaning and the popular understanding inspired by these displays? Critiquing Foucauldian assumptions about the pervasive nature of curatorial control of audience reception, this chapter explores the practicalities of displaying and visiting municipal displays of ethnography. It exposes the problems of under funding, overcrowding and lack of specialist knowledge which dogged some curatorial attempts to present coherent, comprehensive, ‘scientific’ messages for their visitors and argues that publics formed individual responses to cultural heritage, sometimes rejecting official interpretation and drawing upon wider cultural references and experiences. Juxtaposing curatorial reports with media accounts, it is argued that museum audiences, faced with the displays and interpretation produced under such circumstances, struggled to engage with curatorial intent, instead drawing on their own experiences of Empire that had been formed away from the museum in more informal, sociable and peopled circumstances. Research into the reactions of museum visitors of the past is notoriously difficult. Given the paucity of literature which has attempted to document or engage with the thoughts and responses of the historic museum visitor, this chapter analyses a range of potential methodologies and explicitly advocates the merits of placing museum-visiting in a wider context of public cultural production and consumption. By sourcing commentaries on other cultural proceedings away from the museum – the missionary fair, the charity bazaar, the theatre and the public lecture – a comparative picture or ‘contextual shadow’ can be built and used to inform our understanding of public notions of museum-going.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationCurating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience
EditorsSarah Longair, John McAleer
Place of PublicationManchester, UK
PublisherManchester University Press
Pages37-55
Number of pages19
Publication statusPublished - 2012

Fingerprint

Provincial Museum
Cultural Consumption
Proceedings
Merit
Material Culture
Reception
Methodology
Historic
Overcrowding
Funding
Ethnography
Cultural Heritage
Public Lectures
Missionaries
Contextual
Charity
Cultural Production
Sourcing

Bibliographical note

© 2011 Museum Ethnographers Group

Cite this

Wintle, C. (2012). Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950. In S. Longair, & J. McAleer (Eds.), Curating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience (pp. 37-55). Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.
Wintle, Claire. / Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950. Curating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience. editor / Sarah Longair ; John McAleer. Manchester, UK : Manchester University Press, 2012. pp. 37-55
@inbook{4d29f90ae0694eb3b61ecb3dae76d2d5,
title = "Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950",
abstract = "By the first half of the twentieth century, vast numbers of the UK’s towns and cities had formed their own municipal museums and their collections had swelled with non-European material culture sourced from across the world. Such institutions provided a British public with a unique medium through which to comprehend and appropriate their Empire and its peoples, but what were the messages that provincial museums conveyed, and how where they received by local audiences? What was the relationship between intended meaning and the popular understanding inspired by these displays? Critiquing Foucauldian assumptions about the pervasive nature of curatorial control of audience reception, this chapter explores the practicalities of displaying and visiting municipal displays of ethnography. It exposes the problems of under funding, overcrowding and lack of specialist knowledge which dogged some curatorial attempts to present coherent, comprehensive, ‘scientific’ messages for their visitors and argues that publics formed individual responses to cultural heritage, sometimes rejecting official interpretation and drawing upon wider cultural references and experiences. Juxtaposing curatorial reports with media accounts, it is argued that museum audiences, faced with the displays and interpretation produced under such circumstances, struggled to engage with curatorial intent, instead drawing on their own experiences of Empire that had been formed away from the museum in more informal, sociable and peopled circumstances. Research into the reactions of museum visitors of the past is notoriously difficult. Given the paucity of literature which has attempted to document or engage with the thoughts and responses of the historic museum visitor, this chapter analyses a range of potential methodologies and explicitly advocates the merits of placing museum-visiting in a wider context of public cultural production and consumption. By sourcing commentaries on other cultural proceedings away from the museum – the missionary fair, the charity bazaar, the theatre and the public lecture – a comparative picture or ‘contextual shadow’ can be built and used to inform our understanding of public notions of museum-going.",
author = "Claire Wintle",
note = "{\circledC} 2011 Museum Ethnographers Group",
year = "2012",
language = "English",
pages = "37--55",
editor = "Sarah Longair and John McAleer",
booktitle = "Curating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience",
publisher = "Manchester University Press",

}

Wintle, C 2012, Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950. in S Longair & J McAleer (eds), Curating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience. Manchester University Press, Manchester, UK, pp. 37-55.

Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950. / Wintle, Claire.

Curating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience. ed. / Sarah Longair; John McAleer. Manchester, UK : Manchester University Press, 2012. p. 37-55.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference proceeding with ISSN or ISBNChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950

AU - Wintle, Claire

N1 - © 2011 Museum Ethnographers Group

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - By the first half of the twentieth century, vast numbers of the UK’s towns and cities had formed their own municipal museums and their collections had swelled with non-European material culture sourced from across the world. Such institutions provided a British public with a unique medium through which to comprehend and appropriate their Empire and its peoples, but what were the messages that provincial museums conveyed, and how where they received by local audiences? What was the relationship between intended meaning and the popular understanding inspired by these displays? Critiquing Foucauldian assumptions about the pervasive nature of curatorial control of audience reception, this chapter explores the practicalities of displaying and visiting municipal displays of ethnography. It exposes the problems of under funding, overcrowding and lack of specialist knowledge which dogged some curatorial attempts to present coherent, comprehensive, ‘scientific’ messages for their visitors and argues that publics formed individual responses to cultural heritage, sometimes rejecting official interpretation and drawing upon wider cultural references and experiences. Juxtaposing curatorial reports with media accounts, it is argued that museum audiences, faced with the displays and interpretation produced under such circumstances, struggled to engage with curatorial intent, instead drawing on their own experiences of Empire that had been formed away from the museum in more informal, sociable and peopled circumstances. Research into the reactions of museum visitors of the past is notoriously difficult. Given the paucity of literature which has attempted to document or engage with the thoughts and responses of the historic museum visitor, this chapter analyses a range of potential methodologies and explicitly advocates the merits of placing museum-visiting in a wider context of public cultural production and consumption. By sourcing commentaries on other cultural proceedings away from the museum – the missionary fair, the charity bazaar, the theatre and the public lecture – a comparative picture or ‘contextual shadow’ can be built and used to inform our understanding of public notions of museum-going.

AB - By the first half of the twentieth century, vast numbers of the UK’s towns and cities had formed their own municipal museums and their collections had swelled with non-European material culture sourced from across the world. Such institutions provided a British public with a unique medium through which to comprehend and appropriate their Empire and its peoples, but what were the messages that provincial museums conveyed, and how where they received by local audiences? What was the relationship between intended meaning and the popular understanding inspired by these displays? Critiquing Foucauldian assumptions about the pervasive nature of curatorial control of audience reception, this chapter explores the practicalities of displaying and visiting municipal displays of ethnography. It exposes the problems of under funding, overcrowding and lack of specialist knowledge which dogged some curatorial attempts to present coherent, comprehensive, ‘scientific’ messages for their visitors and argues that publics formed individual responses to cultural heritage, sometimes rejecting official interpretation and drawing upon wider cultural references and experiences. Juxtaposing curatorial reports with media accounts, it is argued that museum audiences, faced with the displays and interpretation produced under such circumstances, struggled to engage with curatorial intent, instead drawing on their own experiences of Empire that had been formed away from the museum in more informal, sociable and peopled circumstances. Research into the reactions of museum visitors of the past is notoriously difficult. Given the paucity of literature which has attempted to document or engage with the thoughts and responses of the historic museum visitor, this chapter analyses a range of potential methodologies and explicitly advocates the merits of placing museum-visiting in a wider context of public cultural production and consumption. By sourcing commentaries on other cultural proceedings away from the museum – the missionary fair, the charity bazaar, the theatre and the public lecture – a comparative picture or ‘contextual shadow’ can be built and used to inform our understanding of public notions of museum-going.

M3 - Chapter

SP - 37

EP - 55

BT - Curating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience

A2 - Longair, Sarah

A2 - McAleer, John

PB - Manchester University Press

CY - Manchester, UK

ER -

Wintle C. Visiting the Empire at the Provincial Museum, 1900-1950. In Longair S, McAleer J, editors, Curating Empire: Museums and the British Imperial Experience. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press. 2012. p. 37-55