Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review

Benjamin Marent, Rudolf Forster, Peter Nowak

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Participation is a key principle in health promotion. Numerous methods and tools are available and several models are used to guide and evaluate participatory endeavours in the health field. Recently, however, the lack of conceptual clarity and the normative underpinning of participation have been criticized and more substantiation by social theories has been suggested. To identify theoretical approaches applied to the topic so far and elaborate their potential contribution, a systematic literature review was conducted. Very few papers were identified that included substantial use of social theories. Their main arguments were grouped and critically discussed within a framework of three key questions. The first analyses the functions of participation and expands either the ‘democratic' or ‘utilitarian' perspective commonly suggested. The second asks how lay actors can be constituted as interested and competent stakeholders within their socio-political environments. The third complements an actor-focused perspective by elaborating participatory processes as asymmetric and conflictual. We conclude that the theoretical contributions available offer relevant stimulation for the conceptualization and implementation of participation in health promotion. Future theoretical work could benefit from cross-fertilization with theoretical debates in other areas of health promotion and from more explicitly elaborating the social context within which participation takes place.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)188-207
Number of pages20
JournalSocial Theory and Health
Volume10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 22 Feb 2012

Fingerprint

literature review
social theory
stakeholder
health
participation

Bibliographical note

This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published in Social Theory and Health. The definitive publisher-authenticated version Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review, Social Theory & Health 10, 188-207 is available online at: http://www.palgrave-journals.com/sth/journal/v10/n2/full/sth20122a.html

Keywords

  • health promotion
  • participation
  • lay participation
  • decision-making
  • social theory

Cite this

Marent, Benjamin ; Forster, Rudolf ; Nowak, Peter. / Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review. In: Social Theory and Health. 2012 ; Vol. 10. pp. 188-207.
@article{0512e4b61f4c40e38dbe5d3ef769f03d,
title = "Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review",
abstract = "Participation is a key principle in health promotion. Numerous methods and tools are available and several models are used to guide and evaluate participatory endeavours in the health field. Recently, however, the lack of conceptual clarity and the normative underpinning of participation have been criticized and more substantiation by social theories has been suggested. To identify theoretical approaches applied to the topic so far and elaborate their potential contribution, a systematic literature review was conducted. Very few papers were identified that included substantial use of social theories. Their main arguments were grouped and critically discussed within a framework of three key questions. The first analyses the functions of participation and expands either the ‘democratic' or ‘utilitarian' perspective commonly suggested. The second asks how lay actors can be constituted as interested and competent stakeholders within their socio-political environments. The third complements an actor-focused perspective by elaborating participatory processes as asymmetric and conflictual. We conclude that the theoretical contributions available offer relevant stimulation for the conceptualization and implementation of participation in health promotion. Future theoretical work could benefit from cross-fertilization with theoretical debates in other areas of health promotion and from more explicitly elaborating the social context within which participation takes place.",
keywords = "health promotion, participation, lay participation, decision-making, social theory",
author = "Benjamin Marent and Rudolf Forster and Peter Nowak",
note = "This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published in Social Theory and Health. The definitive publisher-authenticated version Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review, Social Theory & Health 10, 188-207 is available online at: http://www.palgrave-journals.com/sth/journal/v10/n2/full/sth20122a.html",
year = "2012",
month = "2",
day = "22",
doi = "10.1057/sth.2012.2",
language = "English",
volume = "10",
pages = "188--207",
journal = "Social Theory and Health",
issn = "1477-8211",

}

Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review. / Marent, Benjamin; Forster, Rudolf; Nowak, Peter.

In: Social Theory and Health, Vol. 10, 22.02.2012, p. 188-207.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review

AU - Marent, Benjamin

AU - Forster, Rudolf

AU - Nowak, Peter

N1 - This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published in Social Theory and Health. The definitive publisher-authenticated version Theorizing participation in health promotion: A literature review, Social Theory & Health 10, 188-207 is available online at: http://www.palgrave-journals.com/sth/journal/v10/n2/full/sth20122a.html

PY - 2012/2/22

Y1 - 2012/2/22

N2 - Participation is a key principle in health promotion. Numerous methods and tools are available and several models are used to guide and evaluate participatory endeavours in the health field. Recently, however, the lack of conceptual clarity and the normative underpinning of participation have been criticized and more substantiation by social theories has been suggested. To identify theoretical approaches applied to the topic so far and elaborate their potential contribution, a systematic literature review was conducted. Very few papers were identified that included substantial use of social theories. Their main arguments were grouped and critically discussed within a framework of three key questions. The first analyses the functions of participation and expands either the ‘democratic' or ‘utilitarian' perspective commonly suggested. The second asks how lay actors can be constituted as interested and competent stakeholders within their socio-political environments. The third complements an actor-focused perspective by elaborating participatory processes as asymmetric and conflictual. We conclude that the theoretical contributions available offer relevant stimulation for the conceptualization and implementation of participation in health promotion. Future theoretical work could benefit from cross-fertilization with theoretical debates in other areas of health promotion and from more explicitly elaborating the social context within which participation takes place.

AB - Participation is a key principle in health promotion. Numerous methods and tools are available and several models are used to guide and evaluate participatory endeavours in the health field. Recently, however, the lack of conceptual clarity and the normative underpinning of participation have been criticized and more substantiation by social theories has been suggested. To identify theoretical approaches applied to the topic so far and elaborate their potential contribution, a systematic literature review was conducted. Very few papers were identified that included substantial use of social theories. Their main arguments were grouped and critically discussed within a framework of three key questions. The first analyses the functions of participation and expands either the ‘democratic' or ‘utilitarian' perspective commonly suggested. The second asks how lay actors can be constituted as interested and competent stakeholders within their socio-political environments. The third complements an actor-focused perspective by elaborating participatory processes as asymmetric and conflictual. We conclude that the theoretical contributions available offer relevant stimulation for the conceptualization and implementation of participation in health promotion. Future theoretical work could benefit from cross-fertilization with theoretical debates in other areas of health promotion and from more explicitly elaborating the social context within which participation takes place.

KW - health promotion

KW - participation

KW - lay participation

KW - decision-making

KW - social theory

U2 - 10.1057/sth.2012.2

DO - 10.1057/sth.2012.2

M3 - Article

VL - 10

SP - 188

EP - 207

JO - Social Theory and Health

JF - Social Theory and Health

SN - 1477-8211

ER -