The ‘Partnership Identity’ in Higher Education: Moving From ‘Us’ and ‘Them’ to ‘We’ in Student-Staff Partnership

Lucy Mercer-Mapstone, Elizabeth Marquis, Catherine McConnell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Student-staff partnerships in higher education re-frame the ways that students and staff work together as active collaborators in teaching and learning. Such a radical re-visioning of the relationships between students, staff, and the institutions within which they function is both potentially transformational and a significant challenge given the deeply entrenched identities, and attached norms, that form a part of institutional culture. Explicit examination of how identity formation and navigation influences, and is influenced by, student-staff partnership is an important but under-explored area in the partnership literature. Drawing on structured reflective narratives focused on our own partnership experiences, we employ collaborative autoethnographic methods to explore the nexus of partnership and identity through a social identity lens. Results highlight the need to move away from the labelling of dichotomous student/staff roles and identities in the context of partnership to a more nuanced conception that embraces the multiplicity of identity and diverse dimensions of meaning. We highlight the power of the normative conceptions that we attach to different identities, particularly where dissonance arises should those norms conflict. We discuss how this dissonance was particularly salient for us as we crossed the partnership threshold, only to find that the ethos underlying our new partnership identities contradicted the traditional hierarchical structure of the institutions within which we continued to function. Finally, we propose the existence of a ‘partnership identity’ as providing a space where partners might move away from distinctions between group identities of ‘us’ and them’ to a shared space of ‘we’ as partners and colleagues.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)12-29
Number of pages18
JournalStudent Engagement in Higher Education Journal
Volume2
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 15 Apr 2018

Fingerprint

staff
education
student
norm conflict
identity formation
narrative
examination
Teaching
learning
experience
Group

Bibliographical note

Creative Commons Attribution License

Cite this

@article{f6611427d84d4732a128f81d5ae9eed9,
title = "The ‘Partnership Identity’ in Higher Education: Moving From ‘Us’ and ‘Them’ to ‘We’ in Student-Staff Partnership",
abstract = "Student-staff partnerships in higher education re-frame the ways that students and staff work together as active collaborators in teaching and learning. Such a radical re-visioning of the relationships between students, staff, and the institutions within which they function is both potentially transformational and a significant challenge given the deeply entrenched identities, and attached norms, that form a part of institutional culture. Explicit examination of how identity formation and navigation influences, and is influenced by, student-staff partnership is an important but under-explored area in the partnership literature. Drawing on structured reflective narratives focused on our own partnership experiences, we employ collaborative autoethnographic methods to explore the nexus of partnership and identity through a social identity lens. Results highlight the need to move away from the labelling of dichotomous student/staff roles and identities in the context of partnership to a more nuanced conception that embraces the multiplicity of identity and diverse dimensions of meaning. We highlight the power of the normative conceptions that we attach to different identities, particularly where dissonance arises should those norms conflict. We discuss how this dissonance was particularly salient for us as we crossed the partnership threshold, only to find that the ethos underlying our new partnership identities contradicted the traditional hierarchical structure of the institutions within which we continued to function. Finally, we propose the existence of a ‘partnership identity’ as providing a space where partners might move away from distinctions between group identities of ‘us’ and them’ to a shared space of ‘we’ as partners and colleagues.",
author = "Lucy Mercer-Mapstone and Elizabeth Marquis and Catherine McConnell",
note = "Creative Commons Attribution License",
year = "2018",
month = "4",
day = "15",
language = "English",
volume = "2",
pages = "12--29",
journal = "Student Engagement in Higher Education Journal",
issn = "2399-1836",
number = "1",

}

The ‘Partnership Identity’ in Higher Education: Moving From ‘Us’ and ‘Them’ to ‘We’ in Student-Staff Partnership. / Mercer-Mapstone, Lucy; Marquis, Elizabeth; McConnell, Catherine.

In: Student Engagement in Higher Education Journal, Vol. 2, No. 1, 15.04.2018, p. 12-29.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The ‘Partnership Identity’ in Higher Education: Moving From ‘Us’ and ‘Them’ to ‘We’ in Student-Staff Partnership

AU - Mercer-Mapstone, Lucy

AU - Marquis, Elizabeth

AU - McConnell, Catherine

N1 - Creative Commons Attribution License

PY - 2018/4/15

Y1 - 2018/4/15

N2 - Student-staff partnerships in higher education re-frame the ways that students and staff work together as active collaborators in teaching and learning. Such a radical re-visioning of the relationships between students, staff, and the institutions within which they function is both potentially transformational and a significant challenge given the deeply entrenched identities, and attached norms, that form a part of institutional culture. Explicit examination of how identity formation and navigation influences, and is influenced by, student-staff partnership is an important but under-explored area in the partnership literature. Drawing on structured reflective narratives focused on our own partnership experiences, we employ collaborative autoethnographic methods to explore the nexus of partnership and identity through a social identity lens. Results highlight the need to move away from the labelling of dichotomous student/staff roles and identities in the context of partnership to a more nuanced conception that embraces the multiplicity of identity and diverse dimensions of meaning. We highlight the power of the normative conceptions that we attach to different identities, particularly where dissonance arises should those norms conflict. We discuss how this dissonance was particularly salient for us as we crossed the partnership threshold, only to find that the ethos underlying our new partnership identities contradicted the traditional hierarchical structure of the institutions within which we continued to function. Finally, we propose the existence of a ‘partnership identity’ as providing a space where partners might move away from distinctions between group identities of ‘us’ and them’ to a shared space of ‘we’ as partners and colleagues.

AB - Student-staff partnerships in higher education re-frame the ways that students and staff work together as active collaborators in teaching and learning. Such a radical re-visioning of the relationships between students, staff, and the institutions within which they function is both potentially transformational and a significant challenge given the deeply entrenched identities, and attached norms, that form a part of institutional culture. Explicit examination of how identity formation and navigation influences, and is influenced by, student-staff partnership is an important but under-explored area in the partnership literature. Drawing on structured reflective narratives focused on our own partnership experiences, we employ collaborative autoethnographic methods to explore the nexus of partnership and identity through a social identity lens. Results highlight the need to move away from the labelling of dichotomous student/staff roles and identities in the context of partnership to a more nuanced conception that embraces the multiplicity of identity and diverse dimensions of meaning. We highlight the power of the normative conceptions that we attach to different identities, particularly where dissonance arises should those norms conflict. We discuss how this dissonance was particularly salient for us as we crossed the partnership threshold, only to find that the ethos underlying our new partnership identities contradicted the traditional hierarchical structure of the institutions within which we continued to function. Finally, we propose the existence of a ‘partnership identity’ as providing a space where partners might move away from distinctions between group identities of ‘us’ and them’ to a shared space of ‘we’ as partners and colleagues.

M3 - Article

VL - 2

SP - 12

EP - 29

JO - Student Engagement in Higher Education Journal

JF - Student Engagement in Higher Education Journal

SN - 2399-1836

IS - 1

ER -