Quantifying and reducing researcher subjectivity in the generation of climate indices from documentary sources

George Adamson, David Nash, Stefan Grab

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

Abstract

The generation of index-based series of meteorological phenomena, derived from narrative descriptions of weather and climate in historical documentary sources, is a common method to reconstruct past climatic variability and effectively extend the instrumental record. This study is the first to explicitly examine the degree of inter-rater variability in producing such series, a potential source of bias in index-based analyses. Two teams of raters were asked to produce a five-category annual rainfall index series for the same dataset, consisting of transcribed narrative descriptions of meteorological variability for 11 ‘rain-years’ in nineteenth-century Lesotho, originally collected by Nash and Grab (2010). One group of raters (n = 71) comprised of students studying for postgraduate qualifications in climatology or a related discipline; the second group (n = 6) consisted of professional meteorologists and historical climatologists working in southern Africa. Inter-rater reliability was high for both groups, at r = 0.99 for the student raters and r = 0.94 for the professional raters, although ratings provided by the student group disproportionately averaged to the central value (0: normal/seasonal rains) where variability was high. Back-calculation of intraclass correlation using the Spearman-Brown prediction formula showed that a target reliability of 0.9 (considered ‘excellent’ in other published studies) could be obtained with as few as eight student raters, and four professional raters. This number reduced to two when examining a subset of the professional group (n = 4) who had previously published historical climatology papers on southern Africa. We therefore conclude that variability between researchers should be considered minimal where index-based climate reconstructions are generated by trained historical climatologists working in groups of two or more.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1071-1081
Number of pages11
JournalClimate of the Past
Volume18
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 17 May 2022

Keywords

  • climate history
  • historical climatology
  • climate index
  • documentary sources

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Quantifying and reducing researcher subjectivity in the generation of climate indices from documentary sources'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this