Mapping the terrain of selection for social work: a critical analysis.

Cathryn Holmstrom, Imogen Taylor

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper explores the implications of the changing UK policy and regulatory contextsfor the often competing or contradictory interests and agendas operating within the arenaof admission decisions in social work education, highlighted by the introduction of thenew social work degrees in 2003-04 and the associated care councils. Other contextualfactors that impact on admissions to higher education more generally will also be touchedupon, including the widening participation agendas; increased requirements fortransparency of decision making in the selection process; questioning of the predictivequality of A-level scores; and, concern regarding recruitment and retention issues. Acritical review of relevant research into social work admissions processes and outcomes isreported on. The validity of current selection tools is examined utilising research findingsfrom within social work and allied disciplines. The authors argue that the increasedspotlight upon admissions and the ‘front-loading' of gate-keeping into social workeducation is both unrealistic and irresponsible as it omits the crucial ongoing role ofassessment throughout the process of qualifying education.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)519-535
Number of pages17
JournalSocial Work Education
Volume27
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2008

Fingerprint

social work
education
decision making
participation

Keywords

  • Social Work Education
  • Social Work Admissions
  • Selection for Social Work
  • Gate‐keeping

Cite this

@article{0173535602d8456e85ea40fca5833c47,
title = "Mapping the terrain of selection for social work: a critical analysis.",
abstract = "This paper explores the implications of the changing UK policy and regulatory contextsfor the often competing or contradictory interests and agendas operating within the arenaof admission decisions in social work education, highlighted by the introduction of thenew social work degrees in 2003-04 and the associated care councils. Other contextualfactors that impact on admissions to higher education more generally will also be touchedupon, including the widening participation agendas; increased requirements fortransparency of decision making in the selection process; questioning of the predictivequality of A-level scores; and, concern regarding recruitment and retention issues. Acritical review of relevant research into social work admissions processes and outcomes isreported on. The validity of current selection tools is examined utilising research findingsfrom within social work and allied disciplines. The authors argue that the increasedspotlight upon admissions and the ‘front-loading' of gate-keeping into social workeducation is both unrealistic and irresponsible as it omits the crucial ongoing role ofassessment throughout the process of qualifying education.",
keywords = "Social Work Education, Social Work Admissions, Selection for Social Work, Gate‐keeping",
author = "Cathryn Holmstrom and Imogen Taylor",
year = "2008",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10108002615470701379941",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "519--535",
journal = "Social Work Education",
issn = "0261-5479",
number = "5",

}

Mapping the terrain of selection for social work: a critical analysis. / Holmstrom, Cathryn; Taylor, Imogen.

In: Social Work Education, Vol. 27, No. 5, 01.08.2008, p. 519-535.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Mapping the terrain of selection for social work: a critical analysis.

AU - Holmstrom, Cathryn

AU - Taylor, Imogen

PY - 2008/8/1

Y1 - 2008/8/1

N2 - This paper explores the implications of the changing UK policy and regulatory contextsfor the often competing or contradictory interests and agendas operating within the arenaof admission decisions in social work education, highlighted by the introduction of thenew social work degrees in 2003-04 and the associated care councils. Other contextualfactors that impact on admissions to higher education more generally will also be touchedupon, including the widening participation agendas; increased requirements fortransparency of decision making in the selection process; questioning of the predictivequality of A-level scores; and, concern regarding recruitment and retention issues. Acritical review of relevant research into social work admissions processes and outcomes isreported on. The validity of current selection tools is examined utilising research findingsfrom within social work and allied disciplines. The authors argue that the increasedspotlight upon admissions and the ‘front-loading' of gate-keeping into social workeducation is both unrealistic and irresponsible as it omits the crucial ongoing role ofassessment throughout the process of qualifying education.

AB - This paper explores the implications of the changing UK policy and regulatory contextsfor the often competing or contradictory interests and agendas operating within the arenaof admission decisions in social work education, highlighted by the introduction of thenew social work degrees in 2003-04 and the associated care councils. Other contextualfactors that impact on admissions to higher education more generally will also be touchedupon, including the widening participation agendas; increased requirements fortransparency of decision making in the selection process; questioning of the predictivequality of A-level scores; and, concern regarding recruitment and retention issues. Acritical review of relevant research into social work admissions processes and outcomes isreported on. The validity of current selection tools is examined utilising research findingsfrom within social work and allied disciplines. The authors argue that the increasedspotlight upon admissions and the ‘front-loading' of gate-keeping into social workeducation is both unrealistic and irresponsible as it omits the crucial ongoing role ofassessment throughout the process of qualifying education.

KW - Social Work Education

KW - Social Work Admissions

KW - Selection for Social Work

KW - Gate‐keeping

U2 - 10108002615470701379941

DO - 10108002615470701379941

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 519

EP - 535

JO - Social Work Education

JF - Social Work Education

SN - 0261-5479

IS - 5

ER -