How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies

Yuri Sato, Gem Stapleton, Mateja Jamnik, Zohreh Shams, Andrew Blake

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference proceeding with ISSN or ISBNConference contribution with ISSN or ISBNResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Ontologies describe complex world knowledge in that they con-sist of hierarchical relations, such as is-a, which can be expressed by quantifiers or sets, and various binary relations, which can be expressed by links or networks. Should hierarchical relations be distinguished from other binary relations as essentially different ones in building cognitively accessible systems of ontologies? In this study, two kinds of ontology visualizations, a network-based visualization (SOVA) and a set-based visualization (concept dia-grams), are empirically compared in the case of consistency checking. Participants were presented with one diagram and then asked to answer the question of whether the meaning of the diagram was contradictory. Our results showed that SOVA is more effective than concept diagrams, suggesting that to represent hierarchical and binary relations of ontologies in a way based on networks suits human cognition when checking ontologies' consistencies.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction
Place of PublicationNew York, NY
PublisherACM
Pages0-0
Number of pages1
ISBN (Print)9781450352925
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2017
EventThe 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction - Bangkok, Thailand, 14-16 August, 2017
Duration: 1 Jan 2017 → …

Conference

ConferenceThe 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction
Period1/01/17 → …

Fingerprint

ontology
visualization
cognition

Cite this

Sato, Y., Stapleton, G., Jamnik, M., Shams, Z., & Blake, A. (2017). How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies. In The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction (pp. 0-0). New York, NY: ACM.
Sato, Yuri ; Stapleton, Gem ; Jamnik, Mateja ; Shams, Zohreh ; Blake, Andrew. / How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies. The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction. New York, NY : ACM, 2017. pp. 0-0
@inproceedings{258da161c6ff40b280bf8dc7ffea3498,
title = "How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies",
abstract = "Ontologies describe complex world knowledge in that they con-sist of hierarchical relations, such as is-a, which can be expressed by quantifiers or sets, and various binary relations, which can be expressed by links or networks. Should hierarchical relations be distinguished from other binary relations as essentially different ones in building cognitively accessible systems of ontologies? In this study, two kinds of ontology visualizations, a network-based visualization (SOVA) and a set-based visualization (concept dia-grams), are empirically compared in the case of consistency checking. Participants were presented with one diagram and then asked to answer the question of whether the meaning of the diagram was contradictory. Our results showed that SOVA is more effective than concept diagrams, suggesting that to represent hierarchical and binary relations of ontologies in a way based on networks suits human cognition when checking ontologies' consistencies.",
author = "Yuri Sato and Gem Stapleton and Mateja Jamnik and Zohreh Shams and Andrew Blake",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781450352925",
pages = "0--0",
booktitle = "The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction",
publisher = "ACM",

}

Sato, Y, Stapleton, G, Jamnik, M, Shams, Z & Blake, A 2017, How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies. in The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction. ACM, New York, NY, pp. 0-0, The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction, 1/01/17.

How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies. / Sato, Yuri; Stapleton, Gem; Jamnik, Mateja; Shams, Zohreh; Blake, Andrew.

The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction. New York, NY : ACM, 2017. p. 0-0.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference proceeding with ISSN or ISBNConference contribution with ISSN or ISBNResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies

AU - Sato, Yuri

AU - Stapleton, Gem

AU - Jamnik, Mateja

AU - Shams, Zohreh

AU - Blake, Andrew

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Ontologies describe complex world knowledge in that they con-sist of hierarchical relations, such as is-a, which can be expressed by quantifiers or sets, and various binary relations, which can be expressed by links or networks. Should hierarchical relations be distinguished from other binary relations as essentially different ones in building cognitively accessible systems of ontologies? In this study, two kinds of ontology visualizations, a network-based visualization (SOVA) and a set-based visualization (concept dia-grams), are empirically compared in the case of consistency checking. Participants were presented with one diagram and then asked to answer the question of whether the meaning of the diagram was contradictory. Our results showed that SOVA is more effective than concept diagrams, suggesting that to represent hierarchical and binary relations of ontologies in a way based on networks suits human cognition when checking ontologies' consistencies.

AB - Ontologies describe complex world knowledge in that they con-sist of hierarchical relations, such as is-a, which can be expressed by quantifiers or sets, and various binary relations, which can be expressed by links or networks. Should hierarchical relations be distinguished from other binary relations as essentially different ones in building cognitively accessible systems of ontologies? In this study, two kinds of ontology visualizations, a network-based visualization (SOVA) and a set-based visualization (concept dia-grams), are empirically compared in the case of consistency checking. Participants were presented with one diagram and then asked to answer the question of whether the meaning of the diagram was contradictory. Our results showed that SOVA is more effective than concept diagrams, suggesting that to represent hierarchical and binary relations of ontologies in a way based on networks suits human cognition when checking ontologies' consistencies.

M3 - Conference contribution with ISSN or ISBN

SN - 9781450352925

SP - 0

EP - 0

BT - The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction

PB - ACM

CY - New York, NY

ER -

Sato Y, Stapleton G, Jamnik M, Shams Z, Blake A. How Network-based and Set-based Visualizations Aid Consistency Checking in Ontologies. In The 10th International Symposium on Visual Information Communication and Interaction. New York, NY: ACM. 2017. p. 0-0