“Hammered down on every side” versus “just being positive”: A critical discursive approach to health inequality

Emma Anderson, Stephen Gibson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Socio‐economic and health inequality are strongly linked and are increasingly perpetuated by discourses of individual responsibility. However, little research from a critical discursive perspective has addressed how people affected themselves may account for this relationship. This research examined the ways in which people who are in debt, unemployed, or in insecure, minimum‐wage employment construct health and negotiate identities around it. Data from semi-structured interviews with 6 participants were analysed and 3 main interpretative repertoires were identified: a medical repertoire of health as a lack of illness; health as adopting the “right” behaviours and attitudes; and health as being heavily influenced by external factors, such as income and life circumstances. The analysis focuses on how participants managed the tension between these latter 2 repertoires by adopting various subject positions around health: that it is “slipping” away from them; that it requires motivation; and that it is unattainable. Underpinning this is a “common‐sense” idea of health as something that is worked towards through culturally approved actions and attitudes.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)324-335
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of Community and Applied Social Psychology
Volume27
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 22 May 2017

Fingerprint

health
indebtedness
illness
income
responsibility
discourse
lack
interview

Keywords

  • discursive psychology
  • Health
  • Health inequality
  • Identity construction
  • Unemployment

Cite this

@article{56fc20c565314081b2f2000a28e2e2c0,
title = "“Hammered down on every side” versus “just being positive”: A critical discursive approach to health inequality",
abstract = "Socio‐economic and health inequality are strongly linked and are increasingly perpetuated by discourses of individual responsibility. However, little research from a critical discursive perspective has addressed how people affected themselves may account for this relationship. This research examined the ways in which people who are in debt, unemployed, or in insecure, minimum‐wage employment construct health and negotiate identities around it. Data from semi-structured interviews with 6 participants were analysed and 3 main interpretative repertoires were identified: a medical repertoire of health as a lack of illness; health as adopting the “right” behaviours and attitudes; and health as being heavily influenced by external factors, such as income and life circumstances. The analysis focuses on how participants managed the tension between these latter 2 repertoires by adopting various subject positions around health: that it is “slipping” away from them; that it requires motivation; and that it is unattainable. Underpinning this is a “common‐sense” idea of health as something that is worked towards through culturally approved actions and attitudes.",
keywords = "discursive psychology, Health, Health inequality, Identity construction, Unemployment",
author = "Emma Anderson and Stephen Gibson",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
day = "22",
doi = "10.1002/casp.2315",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "324--335",
number = "4",

}

“Hammered down on every side” versus “just being positive” : A critical discursive approach to health inequality. / Anderson, Emma; Gibson, Stephen.

Vol. 27, No. 4, 22.05.2017, p. 324-335.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - “Hammered down on every side” versus “just being positive”

T2 - A critical discursive approach to health inequality

AU - Anderson, Emma

AU - Gibson, Stephen

PY - 2017/5/22

Y1 - 2017/5/22

N2 - Socio‐economic and health inequality are strongly linked and are increasingly perpetuated by discourses of individual responsibility. However, little research from a critical discursive perspective has addressed how people affected themselves may account for this relationship. This research examined the ways in which people who are in debt, unemployed, or in insecure, minimum‐wage employment construct health and negotiate identities around it. Data from semi-structured interviews with 6 participants were analysed and 3 main interpretative repertoires were identified: a medical repertoire of health as a lack of illness; health as adopting the “right” behaviours and attitudes; and health as being heavily influenced by external factors, such as income and life circumstances. The analysis focuses on how participants managed the tension between these latter 2 repertoires by adopting various subject positions around health: that it is “slipping” away from them; that it requires motivation; and that it is unattainable. Underpinning this is a “common‐sense” idea of health as something that is worked towards through culturally approved actions and attitudes.

AB - Socio‐economic and health inequality are strongly linked and are increasingly perpetuated by discourses of individual responsibility. However, little research from a critical discursive perspective has addressed how people affected themselves may account for this relationship. This research examined the ways in which people who are in debt, unemployed, or in insecure, minimum‐wage employment construct health and negotiate identities around it. Data from semi-structured interviews with 6 participants were analysed and 3 main interpretative repertoires were identified: a medical repertoire of health as a lack of illness; health as adopting the “right” behaviours and attitudes; and health as being heavily influenced by external factors, such as income and life circumstances. The analysis focuses on how participants managed the tension between these latter 2 repertoires by adopting various subject positions around health: that it is “slipping” away from them; that it requires motivation; and that it is unattainable. Underpinning this is a “common‐sense” idea of health as something that is worked towards through culturally approved actions and attitudes.

KW - discursive psychology

KW - Health

KW - Health inequality

KW - Identity construction

KW - Unemployment

U2 - 10.1002/casp.2315

DO - 10.1002/casp.2315

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 324

EP - 335

IS - 4

ER -