As “a hedge, as a convenience, a good thing”: Elizabeth Petipher Cash’s continued fashioning of a Plain appearance

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearch

Abstract

From the 1670s, British members of The Religious Society of Friends, better known as Quakers, developed a style of dress to mark out its members. It was striking for its simplicity and termed Plain. It served as “a hedge, a convenience, a good thing – the clergyman of the parish then knew who were Friends and expected certain things of them.” Women Quakers used their Plain garments to resist mainstream fashion, distinguishing them as sartorially and socially separate. In 1860 however, many British Quaker women chose to abandon their Plain garments in favour of highly-fashionable clothes, when the religion’s hierarchy made them optional. Other British Quaker women however, continued to resist the snares of fashionable dress. These women determinably fashioned their Plain clothing as a marker of extreme piety, a marker that, in their religion, was rapidly falling from favour.
This paper will examine the sartorial choices of the British Quaker woman, Elizabeth Petipher Cash. It considers Cash’s reasons for challenging the norms of fashionable clothing by resisting to incorporate mainstream styles until 1894. It will examine her surviving garments held at Killerton House National Trust Devon, alongside her surviving writings. Furthermore, Pierre Bordieu alongside Petr Bogatyrev’s theories serve as a framework to illustrate how Plain and fashionable dress were treated as opposing forces that were constantly weighed and negotiated by Quaker women mindful of the power of dress to express resistance or conformity.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 15 Feb 2019
EventCAA Annual Conference - New York, New York, United States
Duration: 13 Feb 201916 Feb 2019
https://caa.confex.com/caa/2019/meetingapp.cgi/Day/2019-02-15

Conference

ConferenceCAA Annual Conference
CountryUnited States
CityNew York
Period13/02/1916/02/19
Internet address

Fingerprint

Quaker
Hedge
Clothing
Religion
Conformity
1670s
National Trust
Piety
Clothes
Simplicity
Parish
Clergymen

Keywords

  • Fashion
  • resistance
  • Quaker
  • Women
  • nineteenth century
  • Adaptation
  • Conformance

Cite this

Rumball, H. (Accepted/In press). As “a hedge, as a convenience, a good thing”: Elizabeth Petipher Cash’s continued fashioning of a Plain appearance. Paper presented at CAA Annual Conference, New York, United States.
@conference{1e10f022d93643fbbd0bd51abd75a029,
title = "As “a hedge, as a convenience, a good thing”: Elizabeth Petipher Cash’s continued fashioning of a Plain appearance",
abstract = "From the 1670s, British members of The Religious Society of Friends, better known as Quakers, developed a style of dress to mark out its members. It was striking for its simplicity and termed Plain. It served as “a hedge, a convenience, a good thing – the clergyman of the parish then knew who were Friends and expected certain things of them.” Women Quakers used their Plain garments to resist mainstream fashion, distinguishing them as sartorially and socially separate. In 1860 however, many British Quaker women chose to abandon their Plain garments in favour of highly-fashionable clothes, when the religion’s hierarchy made them optional. Other British Quaker women however, continued to resist the snares of fashionable dress. These women determinably fashioned their Plain clothing as a marker of extreme piety, a marker that, in their religion, was rapidly falling from favour. This paper will examine the sartorial choices of the British Quaker woman, Elizabeth Petipher Cash. It considers Cash’s reasons for challenging the norms of fashionable clothing by resisting to incorporate mainstream styles until 1894. It will examine her surviving garments held at Killerton House National Trust Devon, alongside her surviving writings. Furthermore, Pierre Bordieu alongside Petr Bogatyrev’s theories serve as a framework to illustrate how Plain and fashionable dress were treated as opposing forces that were constantly weighed and negotiated by Quaker women mindful of the power of dress to express resistance or conformity.",
keywords = "Fashion, resistance, Quaker, Women, nineteenth century, Adaptation, Conformance",
author = "Hannah Rumball",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "15",
language = "English",
note = "CAA Annual Conference ; Conference date: 13-02-2019 Through 16-02-2019",
url = "https://caa.confex.com/caa/2019/meetingapp.cgi/Day/2019-02-15",

}

Rumball, H 2019, 'As “a hedge, as a convenience, a good thing”: Elizabeth Petipher Cash’s continued fashioning of a Plain appearance' Paper presented at CAA Annual Conference, New York, United States, 13/02/19 - 16/02/19, .

As “a hedge, as a convenience, a good thing” : Elizabeth Petipher Cash’s continued fashioning of a Plain appearance. / Rumball, Hannah.

2019. Paper presented at CAA Annual Conference, New York, United States.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearch

TY - CONF

T1 - As “a hedge, as a convenience, a good thing”

T2 - Elizabeth Petipher Cash’s continued fashioning of a Plain appearance

AU - Rumball, Hannah

PY - 2019/2/15

Y1 - 2019/2/15

N2 - From the 1670s, British members of The Religious Society of Friends, better known as Quakers, developed a style of dress to mark out its members. It was striking for its simplicity and termed Plain. It served as “a hedge, a convenience, a good thing – the clergyman of the parish then knew who were Friends and expected certain things of them.” Women Quakers used their Plain garments to resist mainstream fashion, distinguishing them as sartorially and socially separate. In 1860 however, many British Quaker women chose to abandon their Plain garments in favour of highly-fashionable clothes, when the religion’s hierarchy made them optional. Other British Quaker women however, continued to resist the snares of fashionable dress. These women determinably fashioned their Plain clothing as a marker of extreme piety, a marker that, in their religion, was rapidly falling from favour. This paper will examine the sartorial choices of the British Quaker woman, Elizabeth Petipher Cash. It considers Cash’s reasons for challenging the norms of fashionable clothing by resisting to incorporate mainstream styles until 1894. It will examine her surviving garments held at Killerton House National Trust Devon, alongside her surviving writings. Furthermore, Pierre Bordieu alongside Petr Bogatyrev’s theories serve as a framework to illustrate how Plain and fashionable dress were treated as opposing forces that were constantly weighed and negotiated by Quaker women mindful of the power of dress to express resistance or conformity.

AB - From the 1670s, British members of The Religious Society of Friends, better known as Quakers, developed a style of dress to mark out its members. It was striking for its simplicity and termed Plain. It served as “a hedge, a convenience, a good thing – the clergyman of the parish then knew who were Friends and expected certain things of them.” Women Quakers used their Plain garments to resist mainstream fashion, distinguishing them as sartorially and socially separate. In 1860 however, many British Quaker women chose to abandon their Plain garments in favour of highly-fashionable clothes, when the religion’s hierarchy made them optional. Other British Quaker women however, continued to resist the snares of fashionable dress. These women determinably fashioned their Plain clothing as a marker of extreme piety, a marker that, in their religion, was rapidly falling from favour. This paper will examine the sartorial choices of the British Quaker woman, Elizabeth Petipher Cash. It considers Cash’s reasons for challenging the norms of fashionable clothing by resisting to incorporate mainstream styles until 1894. It will examine her surviving garments held at Killerton House National Trust Devon, alongside her surviving writings. Furthermore, Pierre Bordieu alongside Petr Bogatyrev’s theories serve as a framework to illustrate how Plain and fashionable dress were treated as opposing forces that were constantly weighed and negotiated by Quaker women mindful of the power of dress to express resistance or conformity.

KW - Fashion

KW - resistance

KW - Quaker

KW - Women

KW - nineteenth century

KW - Adaptation

KW - Conformance

M3 - Paper

ER -